Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Neural Foundry's avatar

Fascinating counterfactual that actually respects evolutionary constraints. The anatomy problem you lay out is crucial - intelligence doesnt guarantee tech without the hardware to manipulate the world. That gap between "thinking" and "building" probably applies to cetaceans too, crazy smart but limited by flippers. The quiet civilization idea is haunting though, a species with rich inner lives leaving zero archeological trace. Makes you wonder how many times consciousness emerged and vanished witout any record across deep time.

Expand full comment
MaryBeth Lathrop's avatar

What a great piece, Rob. I have never thought about anything like this...imagining what could have been instead of just trying to learn all that did happen. You have widened my world 🌎 today. Thank you.

Expand full comment

No posts

Ready for more?